The Donald Taylor Trophy, Sponsored by McNasty's
| Donald Taylor Trophy | ||||
| Year | Winner | Runner-up | ||
| 2022 / 23 | Masada | Langdykes | ||
| 2021 / 22 | Masada | Saltoun Arms B | ||
| 2020 / 21 | No Season due to Covid-19 | |||
| 2019 / 20 | Masada | Brig Inn | ||
| 2018 / 19 | Masada | Castle | ||
| 2017 / 18 | Masada | White Cockade | ||
| 2016 / 17 | Northern Bar | Masada | ||
| 2015 / 16 | Masada | Broadsword Bar | ||
| 2014 / 15 | Masada | Brig Inn | ||
| 2013 / 14 | Brig Inn | Masada | ||
| 2012 / 13 | Brig Inn | Northern Bar | ||
| 2011 / 12 | Northern Bar | Brig Inn | ||
| 2010 / 11 | Brig Inn | Northern Bar | ||
| 2009 / 10 | Northern Bar | Brig O’ Dee | ||
| 2008 / 09 | Northern | Brig Inn | ||
| 2007 / 08 | Masada | Butchers Arms | ||
| 2006 / 07 | Masada | Pittodrie | ||
| 2005 / 06 | Masada | Rusty Nail | ||
| 2004 / 05 | Wagleys | Auchmill Inn | ||
| 2003 / 04 | Three Lums Lounge | Donview | ||
| 2002 / 03 | Wagleys | Crown | ||
| 2001 / 02 | Masada | Wagleys | ||
| 2000 / 01 | Wagleys | Kings Highway | ||
| 1999 / 00 | Masada | Northern | ||
| 1998 / 99 | Masada | Wagleys | ||
| 1997 / 98 | Wagleys | Murdos | ||
| 1996 / 97 | Greentrees | Wagleys | ||
| 1995 / 96 | Northern | Fountain | ||
| 1994 / 95 | Northern Lounge | Black Dog | ||
| 1993 / 94 | Northern | Gilcomston | ||
| 1992 / 93 | Tower | Royals | ||
| 1991 / 92 | Charlotte | Lord Byron | ||
| 1990 / 91 | Masada | Portals | ||
| 1989 / 90 | Northern | Portals | ||
| 1988 / 89 | Northern | City | ||
| 1987 / 88 | Northern | White Cockade | ||
| 1986 / 87 | Northern | Three Lums | ||
| 1985 / 86 | Crown | Stewart Lounge | ||
| 1984 / 85 | Crown | Lord Byron | ||
| 1983 / 84 | Northern | Premier Lounge | ||
| 1982 / 83 | Northern | St Machar | ||
| 1981 / 82 | St Machar | Harbour | ||
| Started as Donald Taylor Trophy in '81 | ||||